Norwegian Attorney General Tor Aksel Busch last week decided that a comment cursing Jews, that was made by Norwegian Muslim rapper Kaveh Kholardi during a concert last year, is not anti-Semitic hate speech but rather legitimate criticism of Israel. Kholardi made the comment "f*cking
Jews" at a family-friendly concert in June 2018 to promote diversity.
It was not bad enough that Iranian-born Kholardi thought it was
acceptable to make this comment at his concert. This has been
exacerbated by the fact that two different public officials in Norway have ruled
that this comment does not constitute hate speech. State
Prosecutor Trude Antonsen found that,while derogatory and offensive,
the remark did not constitute a criminal act. This may well be the case
under the laws of Norway, in which case the laws need some adjustment.
But the fact that the attorney general decided that this constitutes
legitimate criticism of Israel, is perhaps more offensive than the
original comment.
I
am enraged by this decision for a number of reasons. When a performing
artist stands up at a public concert and says "f*cking Jews", it seems
to me that his comment is clear and speaks for itself. The fact that he
may say afterwards that he was only joking does not unring the bell or
make his statement any more acceptable. Surely there can be no clearer
example of anti-Semitic speech than this statement. There is no
interpretation required, and there can be no accusation that the
statement was taken out of context. Such a statement is anti-Semitic no
matter what the context. It is offensive, unacceptable and illegal in
many countries around the world.
Why would anybody believe that this statement
translates into criticism of Israel in any way? Aside from the fact
that Israel happens to be a Jewish state, and that many of the Jews
there would be extremely offended by the statement, there is no link
between this curse of Jews and criticism of Israel. In my view,
criticism of Israel may refer to particular policies of the government
or actions of those acting on behalf of the state. A blanket curse of
all Jews in this way has surely nothing to do with legitimate criticism
of Israel. If, for one fleeting moment, I was to accept the fact that
this curse was an act of criticism of Israel, could it in any way be
considered to be legitimate? I have my sincere doubts. Just because I
feel that the Norwegian attorney general has acted to embarrass his
country and insult me and my people, I would not be justified to say
"f*cking Norwegians" as a response. And I would not do so. Instead, I
would be happier and more justified to say "f*ck Tor Aksel Busch for
being an anti-Semite".
The notion that anti-Semitism can be justified
and made politically correct by dressing it up as legitimate criticism
of Israel needs to be opposed as strongly as possible. It is becoming
more and more accepted that anti-Jewish rhetoric and actions are OK
because Israel is deserving of criticism. It is equally common-place
that anti-Semitism is expressed as criticism of Israel. This
legitmisation is reinforced when international bodies and
representatives of national governments confirm its acceptability. It
should be clear that this is not acceptable, and that Jews and Israel
will not tolerate it. The fact that Israel gets involved in the
protection of Jews and Jewish rights around the world, does not justify
anti-Semitism being disguised as legitimate criticism of Israel.
Mr. Busch should be ashamed of his position and
his statement on this matter. He is clearly part of the problem, and
not part of the solution. It is shameful that people like him are left
to be the guardians and judges of what is hate speech and what is
acceptable. This act requires the Norwegian government to fire him from
his position without delay, and condemn him in the strongest possible
terms. The Norwegian government and Norwegian people should be
embarrassed of this decision, and they become complicit by not acting to
reverse it.
As Jews, we have come to expect anti-Semitic
rhetoric from the general public, particularly those who come from
backgrounds that typically hold an entrenched and natural hate towards
Jews. In recent years, laws have been enacted to protect us from having
to tolerate hate speech, laws that also serve to protect other minority
groups. These laws become a joke if they are left under the auspices
of people like Tor Aksel Busch to interpret and implement. This
effectively reinforces anti-Semitism at an institutional and
governmental level. The last time that this happened was in the lead-up
to the annihilation of 6 million Jews as part of an anti-Semitic
genocide sponsored by states and governments, This will never be
allowed to happen again, in spite of haters like Tor Aksel Busch.
1 comment:
I agree in total with the comments made in this blog. Antisemitism is worse than cancer. It is a disease. The difference is it is voluntary.
Post a Comment