The entire process that led to the forming of Israel's 34th
government in 68 years of independence was filled with drama and
unexpected events.
Opinion polls in the weeks leading up
to the election predicted that the two largest parties, the Likud and
the Zionist Union (formed out of a pact between the Labour and Hatnua
parties), would be fighting each other off to form the new government.
The feeling was that one or two seats would separate the parties. Even
the election's exit polls did not predict the extent to which voters
ultimately favoured the Likud over Zionist Union. When the election
result was announced showing that the Likud won 6 seats more than the
Zionist Union, it took everybody in the country by surprise. Even the
members of the Likud were shocked at the size of the victory, especially
in view of the earlier predictions.
The pendulum of
expectation swung in the opposite direction. All of a sudden, there was
the expectation that Prime Minister Netanyahu would form a broad-based,
strong, right-wing coalition government in double quick time. As it
turned out, the formation of the government took way longer than
expected, is the narrowest possible government and is not nearly as
strong as people thought and hoped it would be. With these fluctations
came swings in the public's expectation about how long this government
can reasonably survive, and whether it has the ability to govern and
make the changes that are so needed in Israeli society.
If
the lead-up to the new government contained its fair share of
surprises, the process of forming the government has also been less than
inspiring. The prime minister has been forced to compromise on many
fundamental ideas that his electorate stand opposed to, in the interests
of attracting coalition partners into the government. For example, he
has been forced to go back on legislation, that was put in place during
the previous government, to force ultra-Orthodox yeshivah boys to
undertake military or national service like all others of their age. He
has also been forced to redirect huge sums of money to the
ultra-Orthodox sector, at a time when the Israeli government has
implemented large budget cuts as part of an austerity plan. Many Likud
voters are horrified at these and other concessions.
One
of the persistent rumours that refuses to go away concerns the reported
approach that Prime Minister Netanyahu made to Labour leader Isaac
Herzog to join the coalition. The prime minister is reported to have
approached Herzog on condition that he agrees to abandon his pact with
Tzipi Livni, and bring only the Labour faction into the new government
while leaving Livni and her Hatnua members out of the coalition. Herzog
refused, thereby turning down the opportunity to be part of a national
unity government, and provide Israel with a much more stable coalition.
Has he spited the people of Israel by preferring to see Prime Minister
Netanyahu fail in his endeavours? There are many who believe that he
has chosen the egotistical path, rather than setting his ego aside in
the interests of serving the Israeli electorate.
The
make-up of the new cabinet is also not a huge source of inspiration.
For starters, there are a total of 21 ministers in the new government,
surpassing the 18 ministers that were recently legislated as being the
maximum allowed in any government. Netanyahu was forced to pass an
amendment law through the Knesset to allow him to appoint 21 ministers
to have sufficient jobs to dish out to all coalition partners. The
important job of foreign minister has been left vacant and has been
assumed by the prime minister. He has also retained the communications
ministry, ministry of health and ministry of regional cooperation for
himself. It seems as though Netanyahu may be reserving these in case he
is able to convince Lieberman or others to join the coalition in the
future.
Aryeh Deri, head of Shas, is the new economics
minister. He has recently served a jail sentence and now come out of an
exclusion period, during which he could not serve in a public position,
as a result of having been found guilty of taking bribes while a
government minister. Yoav Galant is the minister of construction. This
is highly controversial seeing as Galant was prevented from taking up
his appointment as the IDF Chief of General Staff due to irregularities
found in the construction of his personal residence on public property.
Miri Regev is the new minster for culture and sport, despite having
made it quite clear that she really wanted to have the welfare
portfolio. Habayit Hayehudi's Ayelet Shaked is probably the most
surprising and high profile appointment to the new government, having
been appointed as the minister of justice. In this position, she has a
huge influence over the appointment of judges to the supreme court, as
well as many other aspects of Israel's judicial policy and justice
system. She has also secured herself a seat in the security cabinet,
the narrow inner cabinet that is responsible for formulating and
implementing Israel's security, defense and foreign policy on a daily
basis. At 39 years-old, she is considered an extremely young
appointment to a critical position, despite clearly being very capable.
It is reported that Likud old-timer Benny Begin only knew of his
appointment to the cabinet, as minister without portfolio, at the moment
that it was announced in the Knesset.
The Knesset
session to present the new government was held on Thursday 14 May. The
session epitomised a circus more than a meeting of Israel's
legislature. At first, Arab members of Knesset created an intentional
and sustained disruption during the prime minister's address, that
resulted in a number of them being evicted from the chamber. A few
other Arab members decided to leave of their own accord in sympathy,
although they did return during the address by the leader of the
opposition. Miri Regev was also issued a warning for heckling and
disruptive behaviour, although managed to survive without being
ejected. Leader of the opposition, Isaac Herzog, delivered a stinging
rebuke and criticism of the prime minister and his new government. He
was heckled by members from the religious parties, who were also issued
with warnings. While the job of the official opposition (and its
leader) is to ensure that the government is held to account, there are
times when it is appropriate for the opposition to support the
government and to show some unity in helping with its efforts. There
are many who feel that this occasion was the perfect opportunity to show
some unity and support.
The inconspicuous start to the
new government continued further with a reshuffle coming less than 10
days into the life of the new government. Likud number 2, Gilad Erdan,
decided that he would be better off working within the new government
rather than from the back benches. While his disagreement with Prime
Minister Netanyahu has not been resolved, Erdan finally agreed to accept
the ministries of public security, strategic affairs and public
diplomacy. Despite him trying to put a spin on why he changed his mind
to justify his actions, it is clear to all that this is a big U-turn on
Erdan's party. Netanyahu was happy to reshuffle his new government in
order to accommodate Erdan. Benny Begin, who was asked to resign his
position as minister without portfolio to accommodate Erdan joining the
cabinet, was not happy to comply with the request.
Despite
the problematic manner in which the government has finally come into
office, it does not detract from the fact that new government has a lot
of important work to do. Israel is under much pressure on the
international diplomatic front to move forward to a peace agreeement
with the Palestinians. It also has to maintain firm security against
those who are determined to destroy her and her people while also
addressing the social and welfare needs for the weakest members of
society in a tough economic climate. All of this needs to achieved in a
climate of lower levels of government spending to manage the economy
responsibly. Israel needs a firm, stable and decisive government that
can make the difficult decisions that confront it. Even though the
manner in which the new government has started out life does not seem to
bode well for the future, we all hope that we will be confounded by the
extent to which the government is able to achieve great things. We
wish them much success.
Showing posts with label Isaac Herzog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Isaac Herzog. Show all posts
Friday, 29 May 2015
Saturday, 28 March 2015
The People of Israel Have Spoken
The ballots have been counted in Israel's
election 2015, and people have recovered from the surprise of a result which
has deviated substantially from the opinion polls and exit polls. I
believe that the surprise comes, not from the result itself, but because of the
extent to which people's expectations were inaccurately set by the polls in the
media. The people of Israel have spoken, and they have spoken loud and
clear.
It is possible to draw a number of conclusions from the comprehensive and unexpected manner in which Prime Minister Netanyahu and his Likud party have been returned to power.
1. Security issues are at the top of the national agenda.
Prime Minister Netanyahu's election platform was based upon security issues, and the nature of the threat that exists against the State of Israel. Some have called it scare-mongering people to believe that Israel is under an existential threat, in order to convince people to vote for him. He even appeared in front of the American Congress during the latter stages of the election campaign, in an attempt to reinforce this point for the Israeli public, the American public and the world at large. With the strength of anti-Israel feeling evident within the international community, within the United Nations and evident from individuals around the world, it hardly comes as a surprise that the Israeli people believe him when he is says that Israel is under threat. And when considering the rhetoric coming from countries like Iran and countries along Israel's borders, it is easy to understand why this feeling is so great. When adding the growing levels of anti-Semitism, much of it dressed up as anti-Israel views, I don't believe that this threat arises from paranoia. It is true to say that Israel is not on the verge of being wiped out, as was the case a few times in the past. The Israeli army is certainly strong enough to stand up to any physical threat to our country. This does not, however, diminish the threat and the desires of Israel's enemies to destroy her. The majority of the Israeli electorate believe that Israel is under a substantial international threat, and have good reason to believe this.
2. Peace with the Palestinians is not a priority.
It is noticeable that the issue of peace with the Palestinians played no role in the election campaigns of any of the parties. The left-wing parties did not seek election on the strength of promises to bring compromises in the interests of reaching peace with the Palestinians, and the right-wing parties did not seek election on the basis that they would not be prepared to enter into peace with the Palestinians. It would appear as though the Israeli public has understood that peace is unattainable with people who are not prepared to recognise that Israel is a Jewish country. This is despite the fact that it is a most basic Israeli aspiration to seek a just and equitable peace. The realisation that the Palestinians are not willing or ready to agree upon the compromises that are necessary to reach a peace, has not been easy to understand. It is tough to accept that the Palestinian leadership has no intention of entering into a peace agreement at all. It is unfortunate that the international community continues to try to squeeze a square peg into a round hole, and to insist that now is the time to force the parties to negotiate to reach a peace agreement. It is even more unfortunate that the international community places the blame on Israel for the lack of progress towards peace.
3. Tzipi Livni is unelectable.
Isaac Herzog sought out Tzipi Livni to join him at the head of the Zionist Union list. The combined list was regarded as greater than the sum of its component parts, and this was borne out by the election result. It seems unlikely that Labour and Hatnua could have secured 24 seats if they had run as separate lists. When agreeing to form the Zionist Union list, Herzog and Livni also agreed to rotate the position of prime minister between the two of them in the event that their list should win the election. There were many in the Labour Party and across the country who wondered why Herzog had agreed to conceed such a strong position to Livni, when her power to bring support to the Zionist Union was questionable. Only one day before the election, Tzipi Livni announced that she was giving up on her right to be prime minister in the rotation agreement. This was widely interpreted as the Zionist Union acknowledging that more people would be inclined to vote for them if they knew that Livni would not be prime minister. The act was also seen as an immense act of weakness on the part of the tough lady. It was also the final word in confirming that Tzipi Livni is unelectable as prime minister. She lost credibility while she migrated from the Likud, across Kadima and Hatnua to ultimately team up with Labour at the opposite end of the political spectrum. She was unable to form a government in 2009, despite her Kadima party won the highest number of seats in the general election. This act of her giving up her right to be prime minister is the final nail in her prime ministerial ambitions. It also opens a broad debate about whether Isaac Herzog is electable as prime minster.
4. Toughness by Israel's leaders on the international stage is desirable and respected.
Prime Minister Netanyahu has always been a master at presenting Israel's case on the international stage, and showing toughness and being unashamed and uncompromising in doing so. He is the new type of Jew that Jabotinsky could only dream of during the years of the pogroms in Eastern Europe. Despite the fact that a number of generations have come and gone since Jabotinsky's time when he dreamed of this Jew, it seems as though Israelis continue to like, respect and desire this quality that Netanyahu possesses. At a time when attacks on Israel in the international community are at an unprecedented high and when anti-Semitism around the world is rising to levels that are unknown since the Shoah, there is something appealing to Israeli eyes and ears in a leader who is prepared to confront and beat these attacks by facing them head-on. The sight of him addressing the US Congress just before the election will have confirmed Netanyahu's ability and willingness to do this for any Israeli who doubted it.
5. Bias in the media counts for nothing.
There can be no doubt that the Israeli media waged a campaign against Prime Minister Netanyahu in order to remove him from the prime minister's residence. He tried calling out the Yediot Haachronot and its online version Ynet during the course of the election campaign, by accusing the editor Noni Moses of publishing untruths in an attempt to discredit him. Israel's media, and its lack of independence and editorial integrity, has come under scrutiny in recent months. It is not only the anti-Netanyahu camp that stands accused, but equally Sheldon Adelson's Yisrael Hayom, and its unashamed support for Netanyahu. The Israeli people have shown that, despite the vicious and overwhelming anti-Netanyahu sentiments published in many Israel printed and online newspapers, they have been able to make up their minds independently about who they wish to lead the country over the next 4 years. Even the opinion polls, that did not even get close to the election result at any point, could not influence the electorate. Since the election result has been made known, the anti-Netanyahu lobby has not given up and continues to castigate Israelis for making the wrong choice in the election. They make an even greater laughing stock of themselves by doing this.
6. Even Obama cannot unseat Netanyahu.
US President Barack Obama refused to meet with Prime Minister Netanyahu during his recent trip to address the US Congress in Washington. The reason given for him not meeting with Netanyahu was that he did not wish to influence Israel's election result in any way. When looking at Obama's actions in the period leading up to the election, and particularly his response to the election result, it seems that nothing could be further from the truth. There is no secret that Obama has no time or patience for Prime Minister Netanyahu. There is no secret that Obama would have been much happier if somebody else, anybody, would have been elected as the prime minister in the election. There were strong rumours that Obama was somehow behind funding the V15 group that rose up in Israel prior to the election in attempt to unseat Netanyahu almost at any price. The slogan of this group, and also much of the rhetoric behind the Zionist Union's election campaign, was anti-Netanyahu. They were encouraging people to vote against Netanyahu, as opposed to enticing people to make a positive choice and to vote for something that they do want. My interpretation of Obama's decision not to meet Netanyahu prior to the election, was a real attempt to influence people to vote against him, and not to stay neutral as he was trying to get us to believe. Perhaps he was concerned that a meeting may have helped to convince people to vote for a man that he would like to see consigned to the dustbin of history. The Israeli people have shown that even the most powerful politician in the world cannot influence their choice. This is not a happy moment for Obama, and his concerted campaign against Netanyahu and Israel since the election has demonstrated that he is a very sore loser. It seems inconceivable that US foreign policy in the Middle East can suddenly change as a result of an election result and a few statements from Netanyahu. Obama's message that "this is not personal" has shown to be completely false. Ultimately, the vote of the Israeli people is stronger, even than Obama.
Israelis are notoriously independent in their views and actions, and have a reputation for being steadfast and stubborn. This has come through very loudly in the 2015 election. And all of this with a turnout of voters in excess of 70%, the highest number since 1999. Even the number of Arab voters was more than 60%, the highest number in history. Despite numerous attempts to influence against the re-election of Prime Minister Netanyahu, he has returned to power with a stronger mandate than before. He is on the verge of becoming Israel's longest-serving prime minister in history. Israel is held up as the only real democracy in the Middle East, and the democratic process has spoken. The time has come for those who preferred a different result, and who would have liked to see Herzog as prime minster, to rally around and accept the result that Israeli democracy has selected. Continuing to fight against it does not serve a purpose. This is not to say that those who justifiably oppose Netanyahu's policies should be silent and not express their views. There is, however, a democratic way of doing this. This does not include intervention from the US president, or unjustified attacks from the media. Democracy is alive and well in Israel, and the people have spoken.
It is possible to draw a number of conclusions from the comprehensive and unexpected manner in which Prime Minister Netanyahu and his Likud party have been returned to power.
1. Security issues are at the top of the national agenda.
Prime Minister Netanyahu's election platform was based upon security issues, and the nature of the threat that exists against the State of Israel. Some have called it scare-mongering people to believe that Israel is under an existential threat, in order to convince people to vote for him. He even appeared in front of the American Congress during the latter stages of the election campaign, in an attempt to reinforce this point for the Israeli public, the American public and the world at large. With the strength of anti-Israel feeling evident within the international community, within the United Nations and evident from individuals around the world, it hardly comes as a surprise that the Israeli people believe him when he is says that Israel is under threat. And when considering the rhetoric coming from countries like Iran and countries along Israel's borders, it is easy to understand why this feeling is so great. When adding the growing levels of anti-Semitism, much of it dressed up as anti-Israel views, I don't believe that this threat arises from paranoia. It is true to say that Israel is not on the verge of being wiped out, as was the case a few times in the past. The Israeli army is certainly strong enough to stand up to any physical threat to our country. This does not, however, diminish the threat and the desires of Israel's enemies to destroy her. The majority of the Israeli electorate believe that Israel is under a substantial international threat, and have good reason to believe this.
2. Peace with the Palestinians is not a priority.
It is noticeable that the issue of peace with the Palestinians played no role in the election campaigns of any of the parties. The left-wing parties did not seek election on the strength of promises to bring compromises in the interests of reaching peace with the Palestinians, and the right-wing parties did not seek election on the basis that they would not be prepared to enter into peace with the Palestinians. It would appear as though the Israeli public has understood that peace is unattainable with people who are not prepared to recognise that Israel is a Jewish country. This is despite the fact that it is a most basic Israeli aspiration to seek a just and equitable peace. The realisation that the Palestinians are not willing or ready to agree upon the compromises that are necessary to reach a peace, has not been easy to understand. It is tough to accept that the Palestinian leadership has no intention of entering into a peace agreement at all. It is unfortunate that the international community continues to try to squeeze a square peg into a round hole, and to insist that now is the time to force the parties to negotiate to reach a peace agreement. It is even more unfortunate that the international community places the blame on Israel for the lack of progress towards peace.
3. Tzipi Livni is unelectable.
Isaac Herzog sought out Tzipi Livni to join him at the head of the Zionist Union list. The combined list was regarded as greater than the sum of its component parts, and this was borne out by the election result. It seems unlikely that Labour and Hatnua could have secured 24 seats if they had run as separate lists. When agreeing to form the Zionist Union list, Herzog and Livni also agreed to rotate the position of prime minister between the two of them in the event that their list should win the election. There were many in the Labour Party and across the country who wondered why Herzog had agreed to conceed such a strong position to Livni, when her power to bring support to the Zionist Union was questionable. Only one day before the election, Tzipi Livni announced that she was giving up on her right to be prime minister in the rotation agreement. This was widely interpreted as the Zionist Union acknowledging that more people would be inclined to vote for them if they knew that Livni would not be prime minister. The act was also seen as an immense act of weakness on the part of the tough lady. It was also the final word in confirming that Tzipi Livni is unelectable as prime minister. She lost credibility while she migrated from the Likud, across Kadima and Hatnua to ultimately team up with Labour at the opposite end of the political spectrum. She was unable to form a government in 2009, despite her Kadima party won the highest number of seats in the general election. This act of her giving up her right to be prime minister is the final nail in her prime ministerial ambitions. It also opens a broad debate about whether Isaac Herzog is electable as prime minster.
4. Toughness by Israel's leaders on the international stage is desirable and respected.
Prime Minister Netanyahu has always been a master at presenting Israel's case on the international stage, and showing toughness and being unashamed and uncompromising in doing so. He is the new type of Jew that Jabotinsky could only dream of during the years of the pogroms in Eastern Europe. Despite the fact that a number of generations have come and gone since Jabotinsky's time when he dreamed of this Jew, it seems as though Israelis continue to like, respect and desire this quality that Netanyahu possesses. At a time when attacks on Israel in the international community are at an unprecedented high and when anti-Semitism around the world is rising to levels that are unknown since the Shoah, there is something appealing to Israeli eyes and ears in a leader who is prepared to confront and beat these attacks by facing them head-on. The sight of him addressing the US Congress just before the election will have confirmed Netanyahu's ability and willingness to do this for any Israeli who doubted it.
5. Bias in the media counts for nothing.
There can be no doubt that the Israeli media waged a campaign against Prime Minister Netanyahu in order to remove him from the prime minister's residence. He tried calling out the Yediot Haachronot and its online version Ynet during the course of the election campaign, by accusing the editor Noni Moses of publishing untruths in an attempt to discredit him. Israel's media, and its lack of independence and editorial integrity, has come under scrutiny in recent months. It is not only the anti-Netanyahu camp that stands accused, but equally Sheldon Adelson's Yisrael Hayom, and its unashamed support for Netanyahu. The Israeli people have shown that, despite the vicious and overwhelming anti-Netanyahu sentiments published in many Israel printed and online newspapers, they have been able to make up their minds independently about who they wish to lead the country over the next 4 years. Even the opinion polls, that did not even get close to the election result at any point, could not influence the electorate. Since the election result has been made known, the anti-Netanyahu lobby has not given up and continues to castigate Israelis for making the wrong choice in the election. They make an even greater laughing stock of themselves by doing this.
6. Even Obama cannot unseat Netanyahu.
US President Barack Obama refused to meet with Prime Minister Netanyahu during his recent trip to address the US Congress in Washington. The reason given for him not meeting with Netanyahu was that he did not wish to influence Israel's election result in any way. When looking at Obama's actions in the period leading up to the election, and particularly his response to the election result, it seems that nothing could be further from the truth. There is no secret that Obama has no time or patience for Prime Minister Netanyahu. There is no secret that Obama would have been much happier if somebody else, anybody, would have been elected as the prime minister in the election. There were strong rumours that Obama was somehow behind funding the V15 group that rose up in Israel prior to the election in attempt to unseat Netanyahu almost at any price. The slogan of this group, and also much of the rhetoric behind the Zionist Union's election campaign, was anti-Netanyahu. They were encouraging people to vote against Netanyahu, as opposed to enticing people to make a positive choice and to vote for something that they do want. My interpretation of Obama's decision not to meet Netanyahu prior to the election, was a real attempt to influence people to vote against him, and not to stay neutral as he was trying to get us to believe. Perhaps he was concerned that a meeting may have helped to convince people to vote for a man that he would like to see consigned to the dustbin of history. The Israeli people have shown that even the most powerful politician in the world cannot influence their choice. This is not a happy moment for Obama, and his concerted campaign against Netanyahu and Israel since the election has demonstrated that he is a very sore loser. It seems inconceivable that US foreign policy in the Middle East can suddenly change as a result of an election result and a few statements from Netanyahu. Obama's message that "this is not personal" has shown to be completely false. Ultimately, the vote of the Israeli people is stronger, even than Obama.
Israelis are notoriously independent in their views and actions, and have a reputation for being steadfast and stubborn. This has come through very loudly in the 2015 election. And all of this with a turnout of voters in excess of 70%, the highest number since 1999. Even the number of Arab voters was more than 60%, the highest number in history. Despite numerous attempts to influence against the re-election of Prime Minister Netanyahu, he has returned to power with a stronger mandate than before. He is on the verge of becoming Israel's longest-serving prime minister in history. Israel is held up as the only real democracy in the Middle East, and the democratic process has spoken. The time has come for those who preferred a different result, and who would have liked to see Herzog as prime minster, to rally around and accept the result that Israeli democracy has selected. Continuing to fight against it does not serve a purpose. This is not to say that those who justifiably oppose Netanyahu's policies should be silent and not express their views. There is, however, a democratic way of doing this. This does not include intervention from the US president, or unjustified attacks from the media. Democracy is alive and well in Israel, and the people have spoken.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
